Latest Headlines
from
The VOICE
 
The Diocese of Newark Online
DIOCESE OF NEWARK - DIOCESAN COUNCIL

Wednesday, September 10, 2003
St. Agnes' Episcopal Church, Little Falls

Approved Minutes of the Meeting


The next meeting will be held on Wednesday, October 8, 2003
St. Agnes' Episcopal Church, Little Falls



Present: The Rt. Rev. John P. Croneberger; President; Mr. John Zinn, Treasurer; Mr. Michael Francaviglia, Secretary; The Rev. Dean Weber, Chancellor.

Elected by Districts: Mr. Donald Cairns, The Rev. Kim Capwell, The Rev. Lu-Ann Conner, Ms. Ann Hirsch, Ms. Naomi Horsky, Ms. Susan Kynor, Mr. Andrew Piccirillo, Ms. Nancy Read, Mr. Don Roberts, The Rev. Dr. Robert A. Schiesler, The Rev. Dr. E. Bevan Stanley, The Rev. Margaret Swetman, Mr. Larry Taber, The Rev. Paul Walker, Ms. Pat Yankus.

Bishop's Appointments: Mr. Steven Boston, Mr. Sidney King, The Rev. Paul Williams.

Absent: The Rev. Randall Day, Mr. Daniel deRonde, The Rev. Prince Singh,The Rev. John F. Stanton.

ECW: Mrs. Anna Byrne.

Others Present: Ms. Lyn Headley-Moore, Mr. Caspar Ewig.

Staff: Canon R. Carter Echols, The Rev. Canon Paul S. Hunt, Bishop Brome, and Mrs. Marva Brome.

VISIONING THREADS UPDATE - DIVERSITY

The Visioning Thread for the evening was Diversity. The Biblical reflection was based on Acts 2:1-12 and discussed in small table groups and reported out to the whole. Members were asked to answer the question posed in verse 12, "What does this mean?" and How could/should/does this shape the ministry imperative of the diocesan leadership?

Ms. Lyn Headley-Moore, Justice Missioner, and Canon Carter Echols, Congregational Development Officer, addressed the Council on the thread of diversity within diocesan ministries.

Ms. Lyn Headley-Moore described the mission work of three justice ministries within the diocese: the Bethsaida Team, the Oasis and the Mission to Dismantle Racism. Each of the groups was a resource for congregational development and ministry work. All are "justice focused and make a trinity of missions representing a wide range of people." The common threads among the three ministries beyond the umbrella of justice were described: accessibility beyond property issues; welcome and genuine hospitality; safety from the risks of oppression and invisibility; inclusion into the life of the congregation; and transformation for everyone. Each ministry had a goal that all will find a church home. Diocesan Council members could help the ministries by assisting to connect them with the districts and the congregations to build a collaborative network of support.

Canon Carter Echols reported on a number of other efforts and work within diverse communities. The work included: the Task Force on Hispanic Ministry chaired by The Rev. David Wolf and Ms. Adrianna Clavijo to strengthen the Hispanic/Latino congregations; the growth of St. Peter's Korean Church which was moving to its own building at the former Church of the Transfiguration in North Bergen; coordination of refugee work along with Lutheran Social Agency; development in skills for diversity ministry through such programs as the presentations by Eric Law, congregational development officer in the Diocese of Los Angeles, in October for laity and clergy; a youth diversity conference planned in the upcoming weeks; and, the convention planning committee commitment to highlight the diversity within the diocese beyond multi-ethnicity.

AGENDA

Motion: It was moved and seconded to adopt the agenda as prepared. The motion was adopted.

MINUTES

Motion: It was moved and seconded to accept the minutes for the meeting of June 11, 2003. The motion to accept the minutes was adopted.

EPISCOPAL COMMUNICATIONS - THE RT. REV. JOHN P. CRONEBERGER

Welcomed Mrs. Anna Byrne, ECW representative; and, Mr. Caspar Ewig, District 3 convener.

Requested prayers for those individuals who were ill, recuperating or had died.

Regarding this year's General Convention, he shared remembrances about his first General Convention in St. Louis in 1973 which included the discussion on women's ordination and adopted changes to the marriage canons; the former issue received extensive media coverage, while the latter seemed to have just simply been accepted, but had ramifications beyond the few days of the convention. Not unlike St. Louis, this year's General Convention had extensive media coverage on the discussion of sexuality, while at the same time the ministry canons were discussed and eventually adopted; unanimously by the House of Bishops and subsequently by the House of Deputies. The ministry canons will be the focus of continuing work during the next triennium.

Announced that The Rev. Herb Tinning had been appointed Archdeacon to work in the formation of the permanent deacons.

DEPLOYMENT/CLERGY TRANSITIONS

The Rev. Canon Paul Hunt reported on recent clergy transitions which included:

The Rev. David Hermanson from Diocese of New Jersey to Lyndhurst; The Rev. Stuart Smith from Diocese of Western New York to Hawthorne; The Rev. Terry Matthews from Pennsylvania to Interim at South Orange; The Rev. Dewey Brown from East Carolina to St. Luke's, Haworth; The Rev. David deSmith to St. David's, Kinnelon; The Rev. Kathryn King from California to All Saints', Bergenfield; The Rev. Susan Saucedo-Sica from Pennsylvania to St. Gregory's, Parsippany; The Rev. Cooper Conway to St. John's, Union City; The Rev. Paul Olssen from New York to St. Paul's, Morris Plains; The Rev. Mariano Gargiulo from Lyndhurst to St.James', Ridgefield; The Rev. Wade Renn from Interim Ridgefield to Interim Harrington Park; The Rev. Jill McNish from Interim Parsippany and Interim Kinnelon; The Rev. Kim Haag from Annunciation, Oradell; The Rev. David Badgley from St. Mary's, Haledon; The Rev. Denise Yarbrough from Towaco to Diocese of Rochester, NY; The Rev. Zachary Fleetwood from St. Peter's, Morristown to Paris, France; The Rev. Bill Gannon from St. Andrew's, Harrington Park to retirement; The Rev. Marshall Shelly from Grace, Madison to New Providence; The Rev. William Rich from St. David's, Kinnelon to Diocese of Long Island; The Rev. Bill Riker from St. Paul's, Morris Plains to retirement; The Rev. James Jannucci from Trinity, Cliffside Park to retirement.

TREASURER'S REPORT

Mr. John Zinn reported on the known and expected financial situations of 2002, 2003 and 2004. The 2002 finances were expected to break even which meant no surplus to carry over into budget year 2004. This meant that the 2004 budget would be difficult without a surplus to carry over from 2002; specifically the surplus from 2001 that was brought into 2003 totaled $125,000. The current cash flow issues related to reimbursements from other entities. The bishop and the CFO were meeting with district clergy during a five week period to talk about the pledge process.

Motion: It was moved and seconded to accept the report, subject to audit. The motion was adopted.

LAY PENSION PLAN

Mr. John Zinn presented the following resolution to modify the current Lay Pension Plan:

Motion: Resolved that the following changes be made in the Lay Pension Plan of the Diocese of Newark effective October 1, 2003:

1. Increase the minimum monthly benefit from $200 per month to $300 per month

2. Change the vesting schedule to the following graded or stepped vesting schedule:

A. 40% at the end of two years of service
B. 60% at the end of three years of service
C. 80% at the end of four years of service
D 100% at the end of five years of service

Supporting information:

The lay pension plan of the Diocese of Newark had been in existence for more than twenty years and predates the lay pension plans currently offered by the Church Pension Fund. All members of the lay staff of the diocese were eligible for the plan after one year of service; employees of Episcopal Community Development (ECD) had their own pension plan and were not part of this plan. Like the clergy pension plan, the lay pension plan was a defined benefit plan, that is, beneficiaries are guaranteed a certain amount of income based upon years of service and average earnings. This is different from a defined contribution plan where beneficiaries receive the amount contributed plus earned investment income, but are not guaranteed any specific amount of income. The Council members were the trustees of the pension plan. Pension payments were calculated by 2% times the five highest average compensation years (HAC) times the number of years of service.

The plan had assets of approximately $1 million, which were invested in the Diocesan Investment Trust. Financial and benefit issues were reviewed with Milliman & Robertson, Inc., an international pension and consulting firm, and Mr. Art Bledsoe, long time volunteer advisor to the diocese of human resource issues. The financial condition of the plan was reviewed annually while benefits were analyzed on a periodic basis, the last benefit changes were made in 1999.

The proposed change in the minimum benefit would be the fourth such adjustment since 1987. This change will impact a very small number of people, almost all of whom have been retired from more than 20 years when salaries, and therefore, pension benefits were much lower. This change had little or no impact on the finances of the pension plan.

The second change related to the vesting schedule, in this context vesting means the point at which a pension benefit is earned. As noted earlier employees are not eligible for pension benefits until after the first year of employment, however the first year does count as a year of service. Under the current plan employees must complete five years of service to be vested, at which point they are 100% percent vested. A more typical approach today is to have graded or stepped vesting whereby employees are gradually vested over a five-year period. Since no pension benefit is earned at the end of the first year, the process begins at the end of the second year when the employee is 40% vested. This continues at a rate of an additional 20% per year until five years when the employee will be 100% vested. There is little or no financial impact on the plan to making this change.

The initial funding for the pension plan came from the diocesan budget. However, for a number of reasons the plan became over funded and no contribution had been made for close to 15 years. An analysis of the current status of the plan, based upon the depressed stock market values at 12/31/02, suggests that while a contribution in 2003 is not mandatory, that this should be looked at closely in 2004. As a result this will be examined as part of the 2004 budget process, which will include an updated asset valuation. There was also a need to prepare updated plan documents for distribution and explanation to the diocesan staff. Once action is taken on these proposed changes, the documents will be prepared and presented to the Council for approval.

Not being recommended were plans to change the number of years used in the calculation from five to three; and an integration of the plan with social security; both of these changes would have benefitted higher salary employees.

JERSEY CITY STRATEGY FUNDS

Mr. John Zinn presented an accounting of the Jersey City Strategy funds from the beginning of 1997 through June 30, 2003 and reviewed the sources and planning process. The sources of these funds were the sale of the property of closed churches in Jersey City and some endowment funds from those churches. Disbursements from these funds fall into the following four major categories:

Strategy Planning - $13,616, funds spent primarily at the beginning of the time frame to plan the direction of the Jersey City Strategy

St. John's Property - $187,369, the costs of maintaining the St. John's property on Summit Avenue in Jersey City. Should this property be sold the proceeds, net of expenses, would become part of the overall funding

Area Ministry - $162,685, funds spent for joint programs and ministries of the three congregations in Jersey City. The bulks of these funds were spent on a joint youth ministry initiative that was discontinued. In June of 2002 the Diocesan Council approved $15,000 in funding for each of the three churches, $3,800 of this figure has been disbursed to Grace Church in Van Vorst.

St. Augustine's Church - $405,598, funds spent in connection with the pre-development work on the new church on Cator Avenue in Jersey City.

One of the decisions that came out of the planning process was that 2/3's of the remaining funds would be dedicated toward the construction of St. Augustine's Church and the remaining 1/3 would go to the Jersey City Area Ministry. As of June 30, 2003 the balance of these funds was almost $2,979,000. The exact allocation of these funds between the Area Ministry and the St. Augustine's project would have to be adjusted for funds disbursed to date. This does not include any estimated value for the St. John's property. In addition the full proceeds of the sale of the Church of the Incarnation property would go into the St. Augustine's project.

COUNCIL TASK FORCE REPORTS

Task force representatives presented status reports.

Missions: The Rev. Canon Paul Hunt reported that the committee had met several times and expressed slight disappointment in the low attendance by council members. The June meeting discussed congregational viability; the August meeting followed up to discuss financial viability for congregations. The next meeting will be held on October 30 and the agenda will define the direction. Some of the liaison responsibilities will be transferred from Department of Missions members to Council members. Other items will be to determine the definition of viability (this will be important when decisions are recommended and finalized on classification of status, i.e., from mission to parish or reverse); and identifying individuals for a small group to read monthly budget reports submitted by the missions and monitor for trends. Tools identified for working with the missions will be useful for the parishes, as well. There followed a lively discussion about the useful of viability tools.

Canon Echols announced the introduction of a multi-week program on "Introduction to Church Management" for five weeks to help church leadership.

DISTRICT ACTIVITIES REPORTS

District representatives reported on activities, programs and planning within their districts.

District 1: Mr. Andrew Piccirillo reported the district was working again with Cross Roads Outdoor Ministries to provide youth programming.

District 10: Ms. Pat Yanks reported that John Zinn spoke on stewardship at the June meeting; a well-done evening.

District 5: The Rev. Paul Williams reported that Ms. Terry Parsons from the national church office spoke at last night's meeting on the topic of stewardship; she used Maslov's Hierarchy of Need meets Jesus Christ.

WARD J. HERBERT FUND BOARD RECOMMENDATIONS

Motion: It was moved and seconded to suspend the rules to allow for the ratification of the Ward J. Herbert Fund Board grant recommendations. The motion was adopted.

Motion: It was moved by The Rev. Paul Walker and seconded that the recommendations for the second cycle of grants recommended by the WJH Fund board's June meeting be ratified. The motion was adopted.

WJH-03-01 Cliffside Park, Trinity - repairs to leak damage, no funding
WJH-03-13 Belleville, Christ - emergency sewer line repair, $2,950
WJH-03-14 Lyndhurst, St. Thomas' - roof replacement - church, parish hall, no funding
WJH-03-15 Montclair, St. Luke's - rectory roof replacement, no funding
WJH-03-16 Bayonne, Trinity - roof replacement - church & center, $2,500
WJH-03-17 Tenafly, Atonement - church auditorium & rectory roof repairs, $2,850
WJH-03-18 Clifton, St. Peter's - heating system replacement, asbestos abatement, sewerline replacement, $23,846
WJH-03-19 Newark, Grace - condensate return piping replacement, $12,500
WJH-03-20 Paramus, St. Matthew's - church floors, water damage, window repairs, $8,804

Total Recommendation to Diocesan Council: $48,000

EPISCOPAL CAPITAL LOAN FUND

Mr. Larry Taber reported the Ward J. Herbert Fund Executive Committee approved a $20,000 loan to Trinity Parish at Bergen Point, Bayonne on July 10, 2003. The loan will fund part of roofing the church and the church's community center. It was projected that the loan would be repaid by 2023 (20-year term). The interest rate was 5%.

Motion: It was moved by Mr. Larry Taber, seconded and adopted to ratify the minutes from the Ward J. Herbert Fund Executive Committee which approved an ECLF loan to Trinity Parish at Bergen Point, Bayonne.

EPISCOPAL CHURCH WOMEN

Mrs. Anna Byrne reported that for the year 2003, two grants were awarded to ministries in the Diocese of Newark: "Outreach to the Hispanic HIV/AIDS Community," sponsored by Church of the Good Shepherd, Fort Lee, for $25,000; and the "Jubilee Family Center, Hoboken," sponsored by All Saint's Church, Hoboken, for $10,000. Since 1969, the diocese had been awarded 46 grants totaling $688,000.

WEB SITE

Ms. Susan Robinson announced that work had begun on the redesign of the web site. The Voice was available on-line and will also provide a Voice in-between electronic issue.

ANNOUNCEMENTS

General Convention report back sessions will be held on Tuesday, September 16; 4-6 p.m. and 7-9 p.m at Church of The Saviour, Denville.

Diaconal ordinations were scheduled: William Albinger, Saturday, September 13, 4 p.m., St. George's, Maplewood; David Cabush, Saturday, September 20, 10 a.m., St. Peter's, Morristown; Kay Locke, Saturday, November 1, Calvary, Summit.

The meeting was adjourned at 8:50 p.m. with prayer by Bishop Croneberger.

Respectfully submitted,

Michael Francaviglia,
Secretary





0--Return to Diocese of Newark Home Page

Return to Top of Page